How to Do a Competitor Content Analysis
A competitor content analysis goes deeper than a basic keyword gap report — it looks at how competitors structure, format, and support their best-performing content, so the findings translate into specific, actionable changes rather than just a longer list of topics to cover.
Pick the right competitors — not just the obvious business rivals
Start with direct business competitors, but cross-check against who's actually ranking in the SERPs for target keywords — often a media publisher, a review-aggregator site, or a tangentially related tool occupies real estate a direct competitor doesn't. Both types are worth analyzing, since they reveal different things: business competitors show category-specific angles, while SERP competitors show what content format and depth is actually winning.
Identify their best-performing content, not just their newest
Use an SEO tool's 'top pages' report (sorted by estimated organic traffic) rather than just browsing a competitor's blog chronologically — the goal is understanding what's actually working for them, which isn't always their most recent or most heavily promoted content. A competitor's top 20 pages by traffic usually reveal clear patterns: a content type, format, or topic cluster that consistently outperforms the rest of their content.
Analyze structure and format, not just topic
For each high-performing competitor page, note: content length, heading structure and how many subtopics it covers, whether it includes original data or just synthesizes existing sources, what content format it uses (listicle, deep guide, tool, comparison table), and where it places calls to action. This level of detail is what separates a useful analysis from a simple topic list — two articles on the same keyword can perform very differently based purely on structure and depth.
Check what's driving their backlinks, separately from their traffic
A page can rank well organically without many backlinks (if it's simply the best match for a lower-competition query), or it can rank well substantially because of a strong backlink profile earned through digital PR or a genuinely link-worthy asset. Pulling the backlink profile for a competitor's top pages specifically (not just their homepage) reveals whether their success is replicable through content quality alone, or whether it depends on a link-earning asset (original research, a free tool, a notable data study) worth building an equivalent of.
Turn findings into specific content briefs, not vague inspiration
The output of a competitor analysis should be concrete: 'competitor X's guide covers 12 subtopics ours misses, uses a comparison table we don't have, and earned links via an original 2024 survey — our version should match the 12 subtopics, add the missing comparison table, and consider a similar original-data angle for link-earning potential.' A finding that doesn't translate into a specific brief change has limited practical value.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Copying a competitor's structure wholesale without checking whether it actually fits your own content's intent and audience.
- Analyzing only competitors' newest content instead of their best-performing content by actual traffic.
- Treating the analysis as a one-time project rather than revisiting it periodically as competitors publish and update their own content.
Related terms
Free tool: Want to see the links behind any site? Use our backlink checker.
FREE BACKLINK PLAN
Build authority with backlinks that matter
Get a shortlist of sites that already link to competitors in your niche, ranked by authority, without doing the outreach research yourself.
- 20 link opportunities matched to your niche
- Discover competitor backlink sources
- Get actionable link-building opportunities
We'll email you the results and occasional SEO tips. Unsubscribe anytime.
Common questions
3-5 gives a reliable pattern without becoming unmanageable — a single competitor's approach might have its own blind spots, while more than 5-6 tends to produce diminishing returns for the added time.
A content gap analysis finds topics competitors cover that you don't; a competitor content analysis goes deeper into how their content on shared or adjacent topics is structured, formatted, and supported — the two are complementary, not the same exercise.
Related Reading
How to Recover Rankings After a Google Update
A sudden traffic drop after a confirmed Google update is stressful, but the recovery process rewards patience and evidence over rapid, reactive changes. Here's a structured approach that avoids the two most common mistakes: doing nothing, and doing too much too fast.
